This is my new favorite joke.
I am now a second-year Master's student at the fabled University of The West in Washington, in the field of English and Creative Writing. Related fields include Dreadlocks, Making Clothing Out of Weed, and Making Beer Sound Like Church.
I'm taking a Graphic Novels class, which has given me a good excuse to re-read
Watchmen for next week. However, I'm also a little trepidated over the whole thing. Although a good number of people in the class are complete nerds like me, others have never read a comic book in their life, and come with all the baggage of being English grad students before being fanboy nerds. I like the teacher a lot thus far (I hope I continue to like her, as she's on my thesis committee.) Everything comes with a price, though, and mine is called
The System of Comics. It's one of those absolutely unreadable books of English "theory" which basically comes down to 1) either telling you things you already know but couching it in difficult language or 2) telling you things you will never, not even if you sell your marriage to the devil, understand. I have a hard time figuring out how the author understood them.
I'm pretty leery of English theory anyway, but not because the different modes of thinking are damaging on their own. The philosophies behind modernism, post-modernism, feminist theory, psychanalytical theory, and deconstruction are all valid and fascinating. It's even fun, sometimes, to discuss books with that mindset. But the ideas have taken precedence over the application. The discipline is written and discussed in such code that is only relevant or interesting to the people involved. In fact, the impenetrable, circular nature of theory writing since the 80s has become a
joke.Also, no one in English critical circles wants to talk about what creative writers want to talk about, which is what makes certain authors successful and how we can steal their techniques. English studies means, at best, finding windows into culture or philosophy by taking studies apart. (I say "at best" because that's the only practical application I can find for most of what goes on in ES.) Uniting English with Creative Writing as supposedly similar disciplines was a silly mistake that is somehow still not rectified at most universities. Creative Writing should be run strictly out of departments like Liberal Studies, where the writers can construct a curriculum that matters, outside their workshops.
Anyway... once I get past all that lingering resentment, I might actually enjoy the class. I'm also taking a class in Medieval Literature, which I had a lot of fun with as an undergrad, but which promises to be a hefty class as a grad student. I'm lucky that most of what I'm doing in Graphic Novels is stuff I would be doing anyway--creating comics, for instance, when my thesis will be a comic, and writing a review of a comic when I already write reviews. The medieval stuff requires much less Middle English reading than I thought it would, which is a relief, and I'm already a bit ahead in having taken three undergrad courses in medieval lit, but still... never think that a grad class will be easy. That's how they get you.